Hybrid Vs. Heirloom Tomatoes – Key Differences & Which One Is Better?

Our experienced writers spend hours deep researching, considering both scientific and experimental info to bring the insights you can trust.  

Quick Answer: Hybrid Vs. Heirloom Tomatoes

Hybrid tomatoes are created by cross-pollination to offer the disease-resistance and higher yield. Heirloom tomatoes are grown from non-hybridized and ages-old seed stock. It has stood the test of time. Both varieties offer certain advantages and disadvantages. So, it is difficult to choose one type over another. You may pick one depending on your requirements.

This article is an ultimate guide on two different varieties of tomatoes, including hybrid and heirloom.

I attempt to compare the pros and cons of these two varieties based on my personal experience and comprehensive research.

Let’s get started!

Hybrid Vs. Heirloom Tomatoes

There is an ongoing debate on which type of tomatoes, including hybrid or heirloom, is best. I have grown both varieties with good results. Both the varieties have advantages and disadvantages.

Here is the breakdown of the strengths and weaknesses of hybrid and heirloom tomatoes so that you can choose for yourself.

All About Hybrid Tomatoes

Hybrid tomatoes are produced by a cross between two different tomato varieties.

They have better yield, consistency, longevity, and improved disease resistance. But, they aren’t flavorful and genetically stable as heirlooms.

Hybrid tomatoes are created by cross-pollinating two different varieties of tomato plants. Usually, the offspring contains good traits from both parents. It may be produced using seeds or through vegetative propagation.

Hybrid tomatoes may have easy care, better yield, improved disease resistance, or a specific growth habit. They can be eaten both raw and cooked.

Check out this video for growing hybrid tomatoes:

Advantages of Hybrid Tomatoes

Hybrid tomatoes have certain advantages including, consistency, improved characteristics, and higher yield.

Hybrid tomatoes are consistent

Hybrid tomatoes are consistent with similarities in size. Also, they have fewer blemishes. The harvested tomatoes stay for a longer time. They are more durable during transport than heirloom tomatoes.

If I want simple red, juicy consistent tomatoes for my dish, I prefer hybrid tomatoes.

Hybrid tomatoes provide improved disease-resistance

Hybrid tomatoes provide improved disease resistance. They may be resistant to fungal diseases, including
Verticillium and Fusarium wilt.

Some cultivars also offer heat-resistant varieties that may withstand high temperatures.

Hybrid tomatoes have a higher yield per plant

As hybrid varieties are designed to withstand harsh weather and pests, they may produce a higher yield. I always have had a reliable harvest with hybrid varieties.

Limitations of Hybrid Tomatoes

Hybrid tomatoes may be pricier, difficult to save, and less flavorful than heirloom varieties.

Hybrid tomato seeds are pricier

Hybrid seeds are more expensive than heirloom tomatoes, as the seed growers need time to produce the hybrid seeds. Also, many gardeners feel that they are not as flavorful as heirloom varieties.

Hybrid tomato seeds are difficult to save

Long term, I find it difficult to replant the seeds from the homegrown hybrid tomatoes.

When I used the seeds from the previous generation, the next generation tomato plants were not identical. Also, some of these seeds did not germinate at all.

However, many gardeners claim that they save the hybrid seeds every year to produce seedlings and fruits. They also say that it is identical to the original type.

All About Heirloom Tomatoes

Heirloom tomatoes are open-pollinated varieties that have been reproduced for generations.

They are flavorful, replantable, offer different varieties, and denote tradition. But, they are susceptible to infections and need care.

Heirloom tomatoes, also known as heritage tomatoes are irregular-shaped, colored fruits. They are open-pollinated by insects or winds.

Also, the variety has been passed down through at least three generations without

They come from the seeds of non-hybridized tomato plants. They may be hand-selected by gardeners in a particular region for generations. They have a shorter shelf-life than hybrids.

Like hybrids, I eat it both raw and cooked.

You may watch this video for more information on heirloom tomatoes:

Advantages of Heirloom tomatoes

Heirloom tomatoes offer a wider choice, replantation, and depth of flavor. It also helps in maintaining tradition.

Heirloom tomatoes come in different varieties

There are hundreds of heirloom tomatoes in different colors, sizes, and flavors. Some types also come in different patterns, including stripes, marbling, streaks, and splotches.

Many heirlooms have vivid colors, including purple, yellow, white, orange, pink, black, and green. If you are looking for a variety, then heirloom tomatoes are my choice.

Heirloom tomato seeds may be replanted

You may save the seeds and grow new generations of tomatoes next year in your garden. I choose the heirloom tomatoes from places with a similar climate as they may be better adaptable.

Also, my heirloom tomatoes had a large number of seeds and were identical to their parents.

Heirloom tomatoes contribute to cultural heritage

As these seeds are handed over from one generation to another, it contributes to cultural heritage. Each heirloom variety indicates different history and background.

It brings about greater genetic diversity in tomato plants. It is considered a treasured and verified variety.

Heirloom tomatoes are flavorful

Many cultivars argue that heirloom tomatoes have a superior taste to hybrid tomatoes. I feel it has a depth of flavor than store-bought tomatoes.

Limitations of Heirloom tomatoes

Heirloom tomatoes may need extra care, have lesser yield, shorter shelf-life, and unusual shapes.

Heirloom tomatoes need care

Heirloom tomatoes need additional care in transportation and storage as their skin bruise easily.

Also, they take a longer time to mature and produce a lesser number of fruits than hybrids. Their yield will be less compared to hybrid tomato plants.

Heirloom tomatoes have shorter shelf-life

If you have purchased tomatoes and left them in the refrigerator for a week, you may be surprised to find them rotten.

These tomatoes have a shorter shelf-life as they are not disease-resistant.

Heirloom tomatoes come in unusual shapes and look!

Some gardeners do not prefer the unusual shapes and looks of heirloom tomatoes. They would want to stick with the red, plumpy, and juicy tomatoes.

Heirloom or Hybrid Tomatoes – Which One Is Better?

Both heirloom and hybrid tomatoes have certain advantages and disadvantages.

You may choose a variety depending on your preference, flavor profile, and availability. Also, you may grow both varieties to reap the benefits of both.

It is difficult to answer whether hybrid or heirloom tomatoes are better.

Here is a simple guideline –

If you are looking for variety, a pop of color to the salads, and a different flavor, then I would recommend heirloom tomatoes.

If you are interested in growing a dependable tomato crop with consistent tomatoes, I would go with hybrid tomatoes.

You may grow both hybrid and heirloom varieties and so, you may get the best of both varieties.


Are all heirloom tomatoes organic and open-pollinated?

Not all heirlooms are organic. Some are treated with pesticides and chemicals as these tomatoes do not have disease and pest resistance. Also, they are open-pollinated. But, not all open-pollinated tomatoes are heirloom tomatoes.

Are hybrid plants GMO?

Hybrid plants are created by crossing two different compatible varieties of plants within the same species manually. In contrast, GMOs are made by high-tech methods, including gene splicing. Sometimes, it yields organisms that would never occur in nature.


I hope this article will provide you with extensive information about hybrid and heirloom tomatoes.

Please write back to us with any queries and suggestions. We are interested to know your experiences in growing hybrid and heirloom tomatoes.

Do share it with your friends and family!